Skip to main content

Amalgamation is a fiasco: Fraser Institute

Amalgamation happened against people's will and not only in Toronto, but also in Montreal. Its promise of cost savings did not materialize.

mississauga-peel-caledonMost of our members have fond memories of North York, “the city with heart” and that is why we borrowed when we chose our slogan to be “the neighbourhood with heart”. Here’s what we learn from Fraser Institute, considered a right-wing think tank:

  • The Fraser report also details the divisions in Toronto illustrated by last year’s municipal election, when the suburban viewpoint embodied by the Ford brothers carried places such as Etobicoke and Scarborough, while those in the central part of the city largely supported Mayor John Tory (open John Tory's policard)’s more urban mandate.
  • Beyond the cultural divisions, Miljan says amalgamation has not necessarily achieved the cost savings it was supposed to.
  • “Unfortunately, we found that it sounds good on paper; certainly you saved a little bit of money by having fewer mayors and municipal councillors, but what people quickly realized was, that is not the biggest ticket item.”
  • She says, for example, staffing costs often go up when municipalities amalgamate because jobs are not eliminated and salaries are brought up to the levels of those in the largest cities.
  • Miljan said her findings about differing political values being forced together under amalgamation are highlighted by the situation in Peel. “That controversy in Peel I think underscores these bigger debates that need to be had.”

Sources / More info: tst-gta

Comments

Popular Articles

Andrei Zodian for City Councillor!

We learned that our president and founder is considering running for office.

TPA blames Police Chief Mark Saunders

The story of police understaffing has been somehow dominating the headlines for quite a while. Although there are far more police per capita in Toronto than in London for instance, Toronto police officers are reportedly so “demoralized” that they took a symbolic vote against Chief Mark Saunders.

Tree planting and TCH closure

The major news of the week is the closing of a housing project at Jane and Finch.

Subscribe Now!

Subscribe in a reader, or by email:
Your email: